Thorn takes fleet case to Lords
Electronics group Thorn will take its appeal against Customs & Excise VAT treatment of its company car purchases to the House of Lords, writes Jon Bunn.
The company, which demerged from Thorn EMI in August, plans to fight on after the Court of Appeal overturned a VAT tribunal decision on Monday.
Customs welcomed the reversal, branding Thorn EMI’s methods a ‘rather clever avoidance scheme’.
Thorn EMI’s actions prompted a VAT law change in 1994 when Customs forecast a potential loss of u600m if the scheme for buying and selling fleet cars was widely adopted. The Court of Appeal backed Customs’ argument that Thorn EMI had used VAT rules allowing companies to simplify group transactions to artificially cut its VAT bill.
A Thorn spokesman said: ‘We thought we had a very good and legitimate case upheld by a VAT tribunal, so the court’s decision was a surprise.
We didn’t define the rules of the pitch, we just played on it.’
Ernst & Young’s tax litigation partner Dario Garcia, who advised on the case, said: ‘The Court of Appeal has decided against us on very narrow technical grounds which we think are wrong. We will be analysing the judgement carefully but our initial opinion is that if the court’s decision was right it would have unexpected implications.’
Price Waterhouse’s head of VAT Richard Watson said: ‘The court took a pragmatic view. There was a taxable event of cars being supplied, therefore there must be tax to be paid.’
The case will take up to a year to reach the Lords.
The numbers you crunch tell a story. Your expertis...
30yEmbracing user-friendly AP systems can turn the tide, streamlining workflows, enhancing compliance, and opening doors to early payment discounts. Read...
View articleOrganisations can enhance their financial operations' efficiency, accuracy, and responsiveness by adopting platforms that offer them self-service cust...
View articleIn a world of instant results and automated workloads, the potential for AP to drive insights and transform results is enormous. But, if you’re still ...
View resourceDiscover how AP dashboards can transform your business by enhancing efficiency and accuracy in tracking key metrics, as revealed by the latest insight...
View articleChancellor John Healey delivers his speech tomorrow afternoon. Here is how practice teams should verify Red Book data, triage incoming client queries,...
View articleReports say Healey has dropped the lower threshold ahead of the 28 October Budget. For private client practices, the real work is in the homes valued ...
View articleWith Conservatives pledging specific IHT cuts, political discourse surrounding a flat estate tax, and unused pension wealth entering the IHT net in Ap...
View articleA high-profile push from ultra-wealthy Britons to tax accumulated capital has put the Treasury in the spotlight. Read More...
View articleHMRC’s newly dropped tax update for the 2027 ISA overhaul reveal a draconian 22% tax on uninvested investment cash and strict curbs on Money Market Fu...
View articleThe 2026 Spring Statement has drawn a final line in the sand for the UK’s tax landscape. With the Chancellor holding firm on thresholds and MTD ITSA m...
View articleAs the £25bn fiscal 'black hole' forces Chancellor Rachel Reeves to eye major tax hikes, this analysis arms accountants with the essential strategic f...
View articleUK landowners face both opportunity and risk when shifting land from agriculture to development. In this article, Naomi Stewart, Head of Tax at Shaw G...
View article